Legal Business

‘Giving the partnership back’: Linklaters to ditch individual partner metrics to target team performance

In a highly symbolic break from its 2000s incarnation, Linklaters is to phase out individual partner metrics and annual assessments to focus on broader measures of team and firm performance.

In a notable shift from numbers-driven assessments, Linklaters is planning to abandon individual partner targets in favour of focusing more on team performance. The Magic Circle firm also wants to ditch annual appraisals for partners, instead hosting more regular feedback sessions for individual partners and teams.

Moving away from the metric-driven approach ushered in under influential former chief Tony Angel during the 2000s, Linklaters global managing partner Gideon Moore proposed the overhaul at Linklaters’ recent annual partners’ meeting in Monaco.

The aim is to ensure assessments give added weight to practice performance as well as client-winning, business development, training and innovation. The move is touted as addressing concerns that its codified approach to benchmarking encouraged defensive gaming of the metrics and a focus on narrow utilisation and billing benchmarks rather than broader business goals. Linklaters’ leadership argues that approach will allow the City giant to focus on cooperation, strategic practice development and its strengths as a lockstep-based firm.

The shift will be watched in the profession as Angel’s pioneering use of metrics was hugely influential in the global legal market.

Moore (pictured) told Legal Business: ‘We won’t have individual partner metrics for billings and other measures. Some might see it as taking away the streetlights and the signposts, but we are looking at other things such as client successes, regional and global practice performance.

‘Being a lockstep firm means two things – pay is less of a distraction and the firm has uniform expertise across the network. With individual metrics, people would be less likely to feel that their indirect contribution was appreciated. We feel this is a way of giving the partnership back to partners.’

Asked how the firm would identify indirect contribution, senior partner Charlie Jacobs said there will be a more active dialogue involving teams and peers.

The proposals come as part of Moore’s ‘Strategy Refresh’ presented to partners as a one-page document at its partnership conference at the end of March.

It also suggests a more flexible approach in contrast to the series of top-down partnership restructurings under Angel and his successor Simon Davies and an attempt to address defensive behaviour among partners that dulled Linklaters’ entrepreneurial edge in recent years.

Linklaters’ leadership maintains that the shift, which came after an extensive consultation period through January to mid-March with partners and staff, has been warmly received by partners.

The shift in tone also reflects the efforts of the incoming leadership team of Moore and Jacobs to build bridges with Linklaters’ partnership after a troubled post-Lehman period dominated by controversial restructurings.

Moore added he had no further plans for major changes to its lockstep. The firm recently saw partners vote for lockstep reforms proposed by Moore, which see the London ladder increased by two years, shifting the ratio from a 10-25 point system over 10 years to a 14-50 point system over 12 years.

matthew.field@legalease.co.uk

For more on the leadership of Moore and senior partner Charlie Jacobs, see ‘Rain men’

Legal Business

Linklaters, Bakers and Mills & Reeve all get a taste on $1.76bn Weetabix deal

St Louis-based consumer goods group Post Holdings is set to take on UK brand Weetabix Food Company for $1.76bn after five years of Chinese ownership, with Baker McKenzie, Linklaters and Mills & Reeve all winning mandates on the deal.

Bakers acted for Post Holdings with a team led by London corporate partner Charles Whitefoord along with Bill Batchelor in Brussels and Regine Corrado in Chicago.

In the US, Post turned to its mainstay adviser Lewis Rice, with partners Tom Zook and Alfred Ludwig working on the deal alongside Bakers.

Linklaters and Ropes & Gray acted for Weetabix owners Bright Foods and Baring Private Equity Asia. The mandate is a repeat deal for Linklaters, which advised the Chinese food group when it took a 60% take in the cereal group in 2012. Shanghai based senior consultant Richard Gu and London corporate partner Carlton Evans lead on the deal for the firm.

Ropes & Gray’s team included London private equity partner Will Rosen and Peng Yu, with support from anti-trust partner Ruchit Patel.

UK national firm Mills & Reeve also picked up a role on the deal, acting for Northamptonshire-based Weetabix’s management team. Mills & Reeve has been a longstanding adviser to Weetabix, also picking up a role acting for the cereal company on its acquisition by Bright Group in 2012, with corporate partner Anthony McGurk advising on both deals.

Post’s management said it aimed to secure £20m in cost synergies from the deal as it takes on the Weetabix brand as well as cereal bar brand Alpen and Weetos. The firm also holds assets in North America and has aimed to expand its international presence into China.

matthew.field@legalbusiness.co.uk

Legal Business

‘Needed a degree of reinvigoration’ – Linklaters reviews banking equity points

Linklaters has undertaken a review of equity points in its finance practice, as banking groups continue to move toward sponsors and away from traditional lenders.

The firm’s London banking team had grown significantly in size through the 2000s, but as the market tightened post-2008 it has become more competitive. According to several City partners, the practice is in need of rebalancing away from senior equity partners with practices focused on traditional lenders.

One former partner added the firm had been aiming to trim between 160 and 180 points from its banking team around nine months ago under the old system, where the top of equity sat at 25 points, the equivalent of around seven partners at the top of the lockstep.

Legal Business understands there were some managed changes to point distribution. Around six exits, about half of which are retirements, are expected from the practice in coming months, while four new banking partners were elected in the firm’s last promotions round. The firm has close to 100 banking partners globally, with around 40 in London.

However, a Linklaters spokesperson said: ‘There are no plans to actively reduce headcount over the next 12 months in our banking or finance practices.’

Another former Linklaters partner said: ‘The team needed a degree of reinvigoration and focus in the more mainstream practice areas that are probably a bit over-partnered. I don’t see how people can justify some of the pay at the top of the lockstep at Linklaters in mainstream banking.’

Linklaters global head of banking Tony Bugg has led the refocusing of the firm’s finance offering since his appointment last year. Last February, Bugg brought in four specialist team heads in a bid to ‘bring in more accountability’.

Linklaters is not the only Magic Circle firm taking a look at its finance team. Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer recently saw the resignation of its sole London-based aviation finance partner, Rob Murphy, as part of a wider review, while two more City finance partners are set to retire this month. Freshfields has been clear it wants to focus more on sponsor clients and has moved some finance partners onto a second-tier of lockstep.

matthew.field@legalease.co.uk

Read more on Linklaters in: ‘Rain men – goodbye Harvard Kool-Aid, hello plain speaking at Linklaters’ c-suite’

Legal Business

‘Needed a degree of reinvigoration’ – Linklaters reviews banking equity points

City firms restructure rewards as practices move from traditional lending

Linklaters has undertaken a review of equity points in its finance practice, as banking groups continue to move toward sponsors and away from traditional lenders.

Legal Business

‘An extremely big deal’: profession lays out key threats as article 50 triggered

Linklaters gives evidence to Lords Committee on Brexit impact

City firms have voiced their concerns over Britain’s arrangements to leave the European Union as prime minister Theresa May pulled the trigger on article 50 last month.

Legal Business

Magic Circle duo land £2.2bn energy deal as antitrust concerns surface

Linklaters and Slaughter and May have taken lead roles as UK energy services giant Wood Group is to acquire its struggling rival Amec Foster Wheeler for £2.2bn amid market competition concerns.

The deal was announced in March and is expected to close in the second half of 2017. Under the terms, Scottish company Wood Group is offering £5.64 per Amec share, for 56% ownership of the combined group.

Legal Business

Linklaters takes Bovis mandate from Freshfields as Slaughters and Camerons line up on builders takeover talks

Linklaters has won a mandate to lead takeover defence for FTSE 250 housebuilder Bovis Homes, advising on merger bids from two rivals, with CMS Cameron McKenna advising prospective buyer Galliford Try. The negotiations saw regular Bovis adviser Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer lose out on the mandate to its Magic Circle rival.

A team led by Linklaters partners Nick Garland and Iain Fenn acted for Bovis, which had previously turned to Freshfields for its advice and lists the firm as its main adviser in its annual report to investors.

Linklaters’ appointment saw its regular client Redrow, the other bidder for Bovis, turn to Slaughter and May for advice. Slaughters’ advice was led by Martin Hattrell with support from partners Sally Wokes, Ed Fife, Bertrand Louveaux and  Dominic Robertson.

Camerons head of equity capital markets Gary Green and corporate partner James Parkes advised Galliford Try in its takeover attempt which would have created a UK housebuilder with a market value of £2.5bn. The firm has advised Galliford Try on several key mandates including the housebuilders’ £125m rights issue back in 2009, its £108m takeover of Linden Homes in 2007, and the acquisitions of Chartdale and Morrison Construction.

Bovis confirmed on 12 March that it had received written preliminary merger proposals from Galliford Try and  Redrow, but had rejected both as they did not ‘reflect the underlying value of the Bovis business’.

A deadline was set of 9 April for further bids, however Redrow did not proceed with a further offer and Galliford Try pulled out of talks earlier this week.

While the domestic merger fell through, Linklaters has also seen UK deal work in its recent mandate advising Amec Foster Wheeler on its £2.2bn takeover by Wood Group, which was advised by Slaughter and May.

matthew.field@legalease.co.uk

Read more in: ‘The M&A Report’

Legal Business

‘Unique opportunity’: Linklaters takes on Goldman restructuring specialist Sarah Mook

Linklaters has hired Goldman Sachs managing director Sarah Mook into the firm’s restructuring team. Mook joins the global restructuring and insolvency practice at the end of June. Her practice includes expertise in special situations, financing and distressed M&A.

Linklaters global head of banking Tony Bugg told Legal Business: ‘When you have the opportunity to bring someone like Sarah into the team you grab it with both hands. Having been at Goldmans she has very diverse skills to bring to the team, it’s a unique opportunity for us.’

Linklaters has seen recent movement in its banking team, with the exit of restructuring partner Yen Sum along with managing associate Jennifer Brennan earlier this year to Sidley Austin.

The hire comes under Bugg (pictured), who was appointed global head of banking in early 2016 after incumbent Gideon Moore was elected the Magic Circle firm’s managing partner.

Last year, Bugg restructured the banking team appointing four new practice heads for leveraged finance, restructuring and insolvency, global loans and financial structuring.

Mook is the second addition Linklaters has taken from the investment bank, bringing in Susana Cao Miranda into the firm’s disputes division. Before joining Goldman Mook was in private practice with Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer.

In its latest partner promotions round, the firm added four new partners into the banking team, including Ian Callaghan in London, Andrew Jennens in Abu Dhabi, Melinda Perera in Luxembourg and Robert Trust in New York. The firm added 26 new partners, including eight into the London office.

Linklaters has recently been rolling out new artificial intelligence tools for banks, with key clients Lloyds and Royal Bank of Scotland both using the firm’s LinkRFI ring-fencing technology, which is used to classify thousands of customer names in a fraction of the time it would take a human to complete.  The firm’s technology team last night won Legal Technology Team of the Year at the Legal Business Awards for the innovation.

matthew.field@legalease.co.uk

For more on Linklaters strategy under Gideon Moore and Charlie Jacobs, see ‘Rain men’.

Legal Business

Linklaters elects 26 new partners as round size increases again but misses female partner target

Linklaters has promoted 26 new lawyers to its partnership, increasing the size of its promotions round for the fourth year in a row.

The firm made up eight new partners in its Silk Street headquarters. The remaining European split has seen four made up in Germany, with three in Frankfurt and one in Munich, three made up in Paris and one a piece in Warsaw, Lisbon, Luxembourg and Amsterdam.

In Asia, the firm made up two partners in Singapore and Hong Kong and one in Shanghai, while the firm also added a further partner to its Abu Dhabi office and another lone partner in the firm’s New York office.

Last year, the firm made up a 24-strong round, but the London cohort represented a larger share, with 10 partners promoted.

The London team sees Fionnghuala Griggs and Kanyaka Ramamurthi made up in corporate; Reza Taylor made up in capital markets; Ian Callaghan in banking; Ilia Ditiatev in projects; Yohan Liyanage made up in TMT and IP; and Mavnick Nerwal and James Morgan in tax.

This year’s promotions came ahead of the firm’s global partners meeting for the first time, with partners voting electronically and allowing the new partners to attend the 2017 partnership conference in Monaco. The male to female split, however, remained disappointingly low, with just five female partners (19%).

Linklaters senior partner Charlie Jacobs (pictured) said: ‘As excited as we are by today’s announcement, we are disappointed that we have failed to reach our target for female partners in this year’s election. We remain absolutely committed to this important goal and acknowledge that despite firm-wide progress on diversity, we must and will strive to do better.’

The City round remains larger than Magic Circle rival Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer’s latest bumper London round, which saw the firm add six partners to its Fleet Street office. The total promotions round saw Freshfields add 18 partners in total across its offices.

matthew.field@legalease.co.uk

Linklaters partner promotions in full:

Alexander Harmse, capital markets, Amsterdam

Andreas Dehio, financial regulation group, Frankfurt

Andrew Jennens, banking, Abu Dhabi

Burkhard Rinne, capital markets, Frankfurt

Christian Schmitt, dispute resolution, Frankfurt

Dirk Horcher, mainstream corporate, Munich

Fionnghuala Griggs, mainstream corporate, London

Ian Callaghan, banking, London

Ilia Ditiatev, projects, London

Iris Leung, capital markets, Hong Kong

James Morgan, tax, London

Janusz Dzianachowski, real estate, Warsaw

Jean-Charles Jais, dispute resolution, Paris

John Xu, mainstream corporate, Shanghai

Kanyaka Ramamurthi, mainstream corporate, London

Laure de Panafieu, employment and incentives, Singapore

Laurent Victor-Michel, mainstream corporate, Paris

Mavnick Nerwal, tax, London

Melinda Perera, banking, Luxembourg

Parthiv Rishi, mainstream corporate, Singapore

Pierre Thomet, mainstream corporate, Paris

Reza Taylor, capital markets, London

Robert Trust, banking, New York

Rui Camacho Palma, tax, Lisbon

Sumit Indwar, financial regulation group, Hong Kong

Yohan Liyanage, TMT IP, London

Legal Business

Linklaters last Magic Circle firm to post spring trainee retention rates as Osborne Clarke keeps 100%

Linklaters, Norton Rose Fulbright and Osborne Clarke have all posted their spring trainee retention rates, with Osborne Clarke keeping 100% of its qualifiers for the second spring in a row.

Linklaters will keep 86% of its trainees, with 44 out of 51 trainees from the cohort staying on to become newly-qualified (NQ) lawyers. There were three resignations in the process. Linklaters rate is better than last year when 83% of trainees were kept on, a selection of 45 from a wider pool of 54.

Richard Hodgson, Linklaters trainee solicitor partner, commented: ‘This figure demonstrates our consistency in producing great results when it comes to developing and retaining the future of the firm.’

An even higher percentage was claimed by Osborne Clarke, with 100% of its six trainees making the grade. The NQs will be based across the firm’s three UK offices in London, Bristol and Thames Valley and have specialisms in real estate, corporate finance, commercial and employment. Osborne Clarke also posted a 100% score in last year’s round, with all seven trainees being retained.

Norton Rose has posted a 50/50 gender split in its trainee retention round, which saw 83% of 24 trainees qualify. However, rates are significantly lower than last year when 22 of 23 trainees, a figure of 96%, were retained.

Earlier this month, Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer posted a retention rate of 84%, keeping on 31 of its 37 trainees. Fellow Magic Circle firm Allen & Overy recorded an 82% retention rate, significantly down from last spring’s figure of 91%. Slaughter and May lead the Magic Circle in terms of retention, with all of its 25 trainees being kept on.

This spring, Clifford Chance (CC) lagged behind the rest of the Magic Circle, keeping on just 31 of its 46 trainees, 67% of its cohort. 43 of CC’s 46 trainees applied for a contract, CC made 33 offers and retained 31. In spring 2016, CC retained 80% of its trainees.

tom.baker@legalease.co.uk