Legal Business

All grown up – HSF’s Belfast volume disputes centre pilots post-merger Australian litigation

legal-business-default

When legacy Herbert Smith set up its volume disputes support centre in Belfast in 2011 it was, despite or perhaps because of the fact that it was at the vanguard of this kind of move, a conservatively promoted step, with initial plans to train only around 20 fee earners, including a mix of solicitors and legal assistants.

Post its merger with Freehills, the growth of this successful centre is evident as its latest pilot to roll out the use of the Belfast centre to its Australian merger partner for Australian litigation gets underway, and the fact that it has, three years later, blown its initial growth targets out of the water with 120 permanent employees, almost evenly split between qualified lawyers and legal assistants.

According to one spokesperson for the firm the Belfast office is already used to support work coming from jurisdictions such as Europe and Hong Kong. The purpose of this latest pilot, which has been on the table since 2012, is to see if the time differences can be overcome and the Belfast office is currently working on a large dispute that is set to finish in April, when the pilot scheme draws to a close.

Libby Jackson, director of the Belfast office told Legal Business: ‘The pilot is focused on ensuring that our teams, our processes and our technology solutions work together seamlessly to deliver to the Australian disputes practice the responsiveness across time zones, cost-efficiency and high quality legal work that the Belfast office has delivered to date to our global clients.’

Jackson commented that she has had some positive feedback from the pilot already and once the pilot concludes in April there will be a review from both the Belfast and Australian perspectives.

She adds: ‘In our experience, clients are increasingly placing value on a more systemised approach to the document intensive aspects of cases but are looking for solutions which further enhance (rather than sacrifice) quality while allowing costs to be controlled more closely.

‘The rapid expansion of the office and the legal services that we offer is due to high levels of client demand and interest.’

david.stevenson@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

Dealwatch: HSF, Clifford Chance and Slaughters take the spotlight in Cineworld expansion

legal-business-default

Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF) has landed a role advising Barclays, JP Morgan and Investec on Cineworld Group‘s £107m rights issue and £504m acquisition of Warsaw-listed Cinema City International, a deal announced yesterday (09 January) that would create a cinema chain with almost 2,000 screens across Europe and Israel. Corporate partners Mike Flockhart and Chris Haynes are leading the team, with US securities advice from Steve Thierbach.

Slaughter and May is advising Cineworld, with corporate partners Mark Zerdin and David Johnson taking the lead.The firm is part of a team of other international firms including Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison (US law), Sołtysiński Kawecki & Szlęzak (Polish law), Djingov, Gouginski, Kyutchukov & Velichkov (Bulgarian law), Nagy és Trócsányi (Hungarian law), Havel, Holásek & Partners (Czech and Slovakian law), Nestor Nestor Diculescu Kingston Petersen (Romanian law) and Herzog Fox & Neeman (Israeli law).

Clifford Chance is acting for Cinema City, with a team led by corporate partners Jonny Myers and Spencer Baylin. Linklaters also has a role on the deal advising other financial advisers.

The deal, should it complete, would combine Cineworld’s 101 UK cinemas with Cinema City’s 99 cinemas that are spread over Israel, Poland and the Czech Republic. The move comes as Cineworld’s rivals have expanded overseas, with Odeon operating in seven countries while Vue Entertainment has a presence in five.

Cineworld’s market value was £590m yesterday while Cinema City was valued at 1.5bn Polish Zloty (£305m). The major attraction of Cinema City could well be the growth that it has enjoyed between 2009 and 2012. During that period, the company saw revenues increase by 14.2% and is reported to have a strong pipeline of screen openings in place to ensure further growth.

The cinema industry has been particularly active deal-wise over the past year: in June 2013 Allen & Overy, Ashurst, Debevoise & Plimpton and Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom all took roles on the £935m sale of Vue Entertainment by private equity firm Doughty Hanson to Canadian investors OMERS Private Equity and Alberta Investment Management Corporation.

david.stevenson@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

Herbert Smith Freehills announces hire of Maitland Chambers Tom Leech QC as Murray Rosen QC retires

legal-business-default

Herbert Smith Freehills has today (9 January) announced the hire of Tom Leech QC, who has left Maitland Chambers to join the top 10 LB100 firm as a partner in its advocacy group in London.

Having joined the Bar in 1988 and taken silk in 2010, Leech has spent his entire career at Maitland Chambers. He is experienced in commercial litigation, professional negligence, company and property litigation, as well as offshore jurisdictions, while his portfolio includes high profile cases in the High Court, Court of Appeal and the House of Lords.

HSF established its advocacy unit in 2005, launched by former 11 Stone Buildings barrister Murray Rosen QC and Littleton Chambers’ Ian Gatt QC, as the firm set itself at the vanguard of firms training its solicitors to be advocates, offering clients greater flexibility in its approach to court work in London and across other offices.

Now comprising three partners and four associates, the addition of Leech will ‘enable the unit to maintain the high quality of advocates’ as Murray Rosen QC prepares to retire in April this year.

Of Leech’s departure, Maitland Chambers’ head Christopher Pymont QC, said: ‘Tom is a highly capable advocate at the very peak of his skills. He has enjoyed a long and distinguished career in these chambers and at the independent Bar. He will be a credit to the HSF Advocacy Unit. We are sorry to see him go but would like to wish him every success in his new role.’

HSF’s London-based head of advocacy Ian Gatt QC added: ‘Hiring a QC of Tom Leech’s calibre is a real coup for the advocacy unit and marks an exciting new phase in our development. Personally and professionally Tom is an excellent fit for our practice and I am delighted to welcome him to the team.’

sarah.downey@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

Revolving doors: HSF loses Perth mining head to Australian rival

legal-business-default

Having completed a crucial overhaul of its management and remuneration structures towards the end of 2013, Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF) would have hoped to get 2014 off to a positive start but has instead suffered another setback, with news that the head of the firm’s mining practice in Perth, Justin Little, will join independent Australian outfit Gilbert + Tobin.

Little will join the Perth office of Gilbert + Tobin in its energy and resources practice. He is a member of the Australian Mining and Petroleum Law Association and has extensive experience advising Australian publically listed mining and resources companies, including BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto, on M&A transactions and equity fundraisings.

Gilbert + Tobin’s Perth managing partner, Michael Blakiston said the appointment reflects the ongoing development of the firm’s energy and resources practice, particularly in the oil and gas industry.

‘I am delighted that a lawyer of Justin’s calibre and ambition is joining our firm,’ he said. ‘Justin will strengthen our presence in Perth and make a valuable contribution to the national growth of our energy and resources practice.’

As the merger between legacy Herbert Smith and Australia’s Freehills in 2012 was partly motivated by the desire to build a strong energy practice, the loss of a high-profile industry expert will come as a blow to the firm and follows the departure energy finance specialist Jason Fox to Bracewell & Guiliani in London in March 2013. This exit added to other big-name losses throughout the year in another core practice area – disputes – with Ted Greeno joining Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan and Simon Bushell leaving for Latham & Watkins.

Further signs of post-merger discontent at a senior level were also evident on the Australian side in late 2013, with Singapore managing partner John Dick and corporate partner Geoffrey Grice also leaving the firm.

david.stevenson@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

Leadership: Herbert Smith Freehills unveils new joint CEOs

legal-business-default

After much speculation, Herbert Smith Freehills announced today that it has appointed Sonya Leydecker (pictured) and Mark Rigotti as joint chief executive officers (CEOs).

The appointments come after a recommendation by the firm’s governance body, the council and following ratification by partners. Leydecker and Rigotti will take their positions for a term of three years after current CEOs David Willis and Gavin Bell step down on 1 May 2014.

Both Leydecker and Rigotti currently sit on the executive board and have strong reputations in both of their legacy firms. Leydecker has been Herbert Smith’s global head of disputes for almost nine years, while Rigotti led legacy Freehills banking, finance and corporate groups and is currently managing partner for clients and industries at HSF.

‘Appointing new leaders represents a further important post-merger milestone, and in Sonya and Mark we are fortunate to have two partners who will bring to the role a powerful combination of management skills, leadership ability and practice experience,’ said senior partner Jonathan Scott.These strengths will provide a strong platform on which to carry out their responsibilities and help deliver our strategy. With new leadership and strong work flows, particularly in the UK and Australia, we are excited about the prospects for 2014.’

Deputy senior partner Mark Crean added: ‘This is a terrific note on which to end what has been a strong first full calendar year for us, marked by the many opportunities we have been given to show how our enhanced capability can benefit clients.’

December has been a particularly busy month in what has been a difficult year for HSF. Earlier this month the firm finally agreed on a combined remuneration system which will see it use a global managed lockstep, although concessions were given to the legacy Freehills side to pay additional bonuses to high billers or star laterals. A statement announcing the move described this as a ‘variable, performance-related component to the system that is specific to Australia partners above a certain point in the lockstep’.

The firm has also seen a number of high-profile departures during its first year as a merged entity, particularly in disputes, with the latest being Tony Dymond leaving for the London office of Debevoise & Plimpton this week.

david.stevenson@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

Revolving doors: Debevoise picks up second experienced HSF litigator

legal-business-default

US firm Debevoise & Plimpton has announced that Tony Dymond, former co-head of Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF) Seoul office, will be joining its London office.

Contentious construction expert Dymond (pictured) is the second high-profile HSF litigator to join Debevoise this year, with Kevin Lloyd joining the firm in July after resigning from HSF in December 2012.

Like Lloyd, Dymond is a renowned litigator with 20 years of experience advising international clients on complex, multi-jurisdictional disputes.

A solicitor-advocate, his practice focuses on high-value construction and engineering disputes in the energy and infrastructure sectors.

Debevoise’s London office has seen significant expansion in its litigation practice, led by former Attorney General Lord Goldsmith QC. The team has grown by 12 lawyers in 2013 alone.

‘Tony Dymond’s arrival is great news for the firm. He is a highly respected lawyer with a truly international practice, and a key addition to our litigation team in London. Tony’s arrival also further demonstrates our commitment to provide premier English law advice to our clients,’ said Michael Blair, presiding partner of Debevoise.

A HSF spokesperson confirmed that Doha-based dispute resolution lawyer James Doe has been promoted to partner in Seoul to replace Dymond, who ‘retired from the partnership’. HSF has had a difficult year following the merger between legacy Herbert Smith and Australian outfit Freehills in October 2012 with senior partner exits, particularly in its signature disputes practice, and a remuneration reform which took some time to get voted through.

But the firm remains upbeat. Lewis McDonald, Seoul managing partner and head of corporate South Korea at HSF, said: ‘We have had a great start to our Korean practice so far and I am grateful for the support Tony has provided to me and the firm during this first phase. The next phase of our development will be significantly bolstered by James who has energy, enthusiasm and the perfect skill-set and regional experience for this market.’

David.stevenson@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

A carve-out before Christmas – HSF agrees compromise to (largely) unite post-merger partner pay

legal-business-default

It was a long time coming but Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF) has finally agreed a compromise to unite equity partner pay just over a year after the union of Herbert Smith and Australian leader Freehills.

The deal will see the two firms combine their partnerships under a ‘global managed lockstep’, a break from previous attempts to usher in more radical performance-based rewards for the combined partnership.

As Legal Business reported three weeks ago, the firm has decided to allow legacy Freehills some latitude when it comes to how they pay their partners.

Both legacy firms will use the same core ladder but the limited carve-outs will allow the legacy Freehills side to pay additional bonuses to high billers or star laterals. A statement announcing the move described this as a ‘variable, performance-related component to the system that is specific to Australia partners above a certain point in the lockstep’. There will also be a common bonus pool to reward ‘exceptional partner performance’.

The new, more merit-based system replaces Herbert Smith’s rigid lockstep, though it will run to the same range as the legacy City firm’s current system, which runs from 43 to 100 points.

CEO David Willis told Legal Business: ‘We went through a sequential consultation process and ended up with one proposal that we put to the partnership. There were lots of ideas put forward during the consultation and some weren’t as popular as others.’

‘The vast majority of the remuneration system is common to both partnerships. The difference for the partners in Australia won’t affect a large number of people. The bonuses allocated annually to all partners will be modest.’

The percentage of the firm’s profit pool that will be allocated to bonuses for legacy Freehills partners is understood to be around 5%.

The firm required a 75% majority vote in each of its partnerships to get the new system through. The vote was completed last week. Partners’ performance will be assessed using a ‘balanced scorecard’ approach, the firm said.

The exceptions from lockstep will not be available to legacy Herbert Smith partners and according to the firm these measures reflect ‘the nature of partner remuneration systems in the Australian market’.

The unusual compromise was agreed after four earlier sets of proposals sent in October failed to win support. These included more radical measures, such as discretionary gates, which were unpopular with London partners. The new system comes into place at the start of the 2014 financial year.

The ratified deal has been viewed as a somewhat unwieldy compromise that was necessary to bridge the two legacy sides of the firm, which will raise questions for some over the degree of integration between the two sides. The two firms combined formally on October 2012.

Legacy Herbert Smith’s lockstep had fixed-share partners serving four years before making it onto the equity ladder, which runs from 43 to 100 points. Freehills operated a core ‘ladder’ running to 120 points, though up to another 40 points can be handed out as bonuses, which are typically given to top-performing partners and laterals. The Freehills models meant that partners can earn well over £1m, in comparison top of equity at Herbert Smith of £933,000 during the 2011/12 year, when the City law firm saw profits per equity (PEP) partner of £840,000.

The firm is also voting on its new chief executive or joint chief executives by the end of the year, as David Willis and Gavin Bell will step down in April 2014. Partners viewed as likely contenders include litigation head Sonya Leydecker, UK managing partner Ian Cox, global head of corporate Mike Ferraro and EMEA managing partner Allen Hanen.

david.stevenson@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

Revolving doors: Strategic growth for Mishcon, Hill Dickinson, Herbert Smith Freehills, Orrick Rambaud and Addleshaw Goddard

legal-business-default

Mishcon de Reya this week (25 November) announced that it is to completely restructure its tax offering, consolidating its real estate, corporate tax, and private tax and wealth planning divisions and invest in the area with the hire King & Wood Mallesons SJ Berwin tax partner John Skoulding and solicitor Charlie Sosna from Berkeley Law.

Focusing on UK and international M&A, management buy-outs and corporate restructurings, among other issues, Skoulding has worked across sectors including betting and gaming, fashion, retail, intellectual property and financial services.

The launch of Mishcon’s new tax practice is said by the top 40 firm to recognise the changing needs of its clients, as their personal and business concerns increasingly overlap, and Andrew Goldstone, head of private tax and wealth planning commented: ‘John and Charlie are great additions to the team – they are joining at a busy and exciting time, not just for our tax practice, but also the firm more broadly.

‘We’ve expanded from 300 employees in 2009, to over 500 in 2012, and have seen a 75% revenue rise within this period. This was achieved by investing in people and securing the best talent, and these new hires demonstrate our on-going commitment to this strategy.’

Also in London, Blake Lapthorn banking and finance partner Claire Wheatley, who launched the top 65 LB100 firm’s City banking practice with her arrival from Clyde & Co in 2009, has joined Hill Dickinson.

Wheatley, who has also held roles at Howard Kennedy, Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer and Clifford Chance since 1988, said: ‘Hill Dickinson has an excellent reputation in the City, particularly within the banking and finance sector and I look forward to drawing on my connections with international banks, property companies and private sector organisations to further develop the team’s well established relationships in the City.’

On the Continent meanwhile, Herbert Smith Freehills’ (HSF) Paris office last Thursday (21 November) announced the growth of its Paris-based Africa, energy and infrastructure teams, with the arrival of Gide Loyrette Nouel oil, gas and mining corporate partner Leïla Hubeaut and JeantetAssocies mining and infrastructure associate Hiba Abi Haidar.

Hubeaut, who before Gide was part of the corporate team at Ernst & Young, combines her oil and gas practice with privatisations and business structuring/restructuring for African nations. Her experience, the firm said in a statement, extends to all regulatory aspects of projects, especially in obtaining permits and other government approvals.

Stéphane Brabant, head of the five-partner, thirty-lawyer Paris energy and infrastructure practice and the global Africa practice at HSF, commented: ‘Leïla and Hiba combine the strong advantages of thorough technical expertise and a solid understanding of the African environment, which will help us provide even better service to our clients investing in the continent.’

Also in the vibrant Paris market, where Speechly Bircham this week launched with the hire of an 11-lawyer team, former SJ Berwin partner Etienne Boursican joined Orrick Rambaud Martel’s regional private equity practice.

Boursican focuses on M&A and capital markets, particularly advising and acting for listed companies in cross-border transactions involving tender offers, sale and purchase of equity stakes, public offerings, private placements and IPOs.

Pascal Agboyibor, Orrick’s Paris office head said: ‘The European M&A market continues to be a favoured destination for international investors with Paris acting as a vital centre for M&A activity throughout the continent.’

Orrick recently advised Paris-based Neolane on its $600 million acquisition by Adobe Systems and represented U-Shin on its $270 million acquisition of Paris-based Valeo S.A.’s access mechanisms business.

Elsewhere, Addleshaw Goddard has strengthened its Arab Gulf Coordination Council (GCC) offering with the hire of K&L Gates head of private equity for the GCC, Andrew Johnston, who joins a month after the hire of Clyde & Co corporate partner Ben Gillespie in Dubai.

Johnston and Gillespie, who will work alongside corporate partners Keith Johnston and Tim Field, join as the 660-lawyer firm invests in new service lines beyond its core offering of international arbitration and construction litigation in the Dubai office, which opened in September 2012 following the hire of Trowers & Hamlins regional head of construction, Andrew Greaves.

International division managing partner Andrew Carpenter said: ‘Andrew and Ben’s hires are the latest in a series of exciting investments we have made to broaden our international capability and to accelerate the growth of our GCC team.

‘Both partners have significant experience of acting in Dubai and the wider region and have practices that can be leveraged across our three GCC offices and the UK, as well as complimenting the investment we have already made in the UAE. Their hires are an exciting milestone and are indicative of our progress and ambitions.’

francesca.fanshawe@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

HSF fallout continues as two Freehills partners quit firm in Singapore

legal-business-default

The fallout from last year’s combination of Herbert Smith and Australia’s Freehills continues to rumble on, with news that HSF‘s Singapore office has been weakened by two senior departures.

Former Freehills Singapore managing partner John Dick has left the firm following corporate partner Geoffrey Grice’s move to Duane Morris & Selvan in Singapore.

Dick is named in The Legal 500 Asia-Pacific as a leading individual for projects and energy, while Brice joined Freehills in 2009 from the state solicitor’s office of Western Australia and has over 20 years’ experience advising on major projects and cross-border transactions in Europe and Asia Pacific.

Singapore was the one jurisdiction where both legacy firms had a presence, although Freehills’ Singapore lawyers moved into Herbert Smith’s offices shortly after the merger went live in October 2012. However, the departures have not been isolated to legacy Freehills, as Herbert Smith energy partner Michelle Chen left to join Jones Day in November last year.

There has also been movement below partner level, with associates from both legacy firms leaving since the merger, such as senior associate Nicolas Watts and Simon Barrell moving to K&L Gates and Norton Rose Fulbright respectively on the Freehills side while litigators Rob Palmer and Chris Bailey both joined Ashurst as partners at the beginning of the year from Herbert Smith.

However, Freehills has also been relocating partners to Singapore, with Nichola Yeomans, an M&A partner, joining the office from Sydney at the beginning of the year.

A spokesman for HSF, confirming the partner departures, said: ‘there are always going to issues with integrating two firms, but this has been said for some time now’.

A continued source of contention within the firm has been the thorny issue of integration of the two financial systems. Talks were held last Friday in London and Monday in Australia as the firm looks for a way to break the deadlock before the departures continue.

david.stevenson@legalease.co.uk

Legal Business

Learning to live together – HSF strives to thrash out compromise on partner pay as key vote looms

legal-business-default

It often seems getting a deal agreed is the hardest part – as in the case of Herbert Smith, which in 2012 agreed to combine with Australian leader Freehills – but working out those thorny integration issues can make you long for the simplicity of a straight merger vote.

Almost 18 months after agreeing its union Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF) is still thrashing out how to make its combined remuneration system work, having originally been expected to agree a model in October that would see the combined firm move to a variant of Freehills’ aggressively modified lockstep.

Four proposed models that were put forward in October failed to win support, leaving the firm searching for an acceptable compromise. One sticking point were proposals to introduce discretionary gates, which displeased London partners wedded to Herbert Smith’s more conservative lockstep regime.

Partners contacted by Legal Business last week indicated that meetings were being held on Friday (15 November) and today (18 November) to finalise proposals for an imminent vote. The official line is that it will take place ‘by mid-December’.

With the issue generating strong feelings at the legacy Herbert Smith partnership, there has been talk that the firm will move to a lightly modified lockstep half way between the legacy firms’ systems. The twist in the tail is the idea that legacy Freehills would retain some scope to pay bonuses for star laterals and high billers that would not be used by legacy Herbert Smith. The unusual move – which is viewed as a compromise to bridge the different sides – would mean the two firms would operate a largely integrated pay model but with limited carve outs for the Australia side of the business.

Legacy Herbert Smith’s lockstep has fixed share partners serving four years before making it onto the equity ladder, which runs from 43 to 100 points. Freehills operates a core ‘ladder’ running to 120 points, though up to another 40 points can be handed out as bonuses, which are typically given to top-performing partners and laterals. The Freehills models means that partners can earn well over £1m, in comparison top of equity at Herbert Smith of £933,000 during the 2011/12 year, when the City law firm saw profits per equity (PEP) partner of £840,000.

The two firms already moved to a single profit pool when the merger went live in October 2012, so have yet to report net income for a full financial year.

One HSF partner commented: ‘Any time you touch remuneration it’s going to be a touchy subject. It forced both sides to think what’s good and what could be better under their respective systems.’

Another partner at the firm comments: ‘It [remuneration reform] was all looking a bit of a fudge last time I looked.’

However, supporters of this compromise see it as better than the two sides simply maintaining fundamentally different ways of rewarding partners.

The remuneration talks come as the firm also prepares to vote on its new chief executive or joint chief executives by the end of the year, as David Willis and Gavin Bell step down in April 2014. One partner said that given the geographical spread of the firm, they expect that the role will continue to operate on a dual basis. Partners viewed as likely contenders include litigation head Sonya Leydecker, UK managing partner Ian Cox, global head of corporate Mike Ferraro and EMEA managing partner Allen Hanen.

david.stevenson@legalease.co.uk